Episodes › Ep. 51 2025-03-18 · 47:33
The Jon Hamm Episode
Episode 51 opens with listener feedback on the Ross Trent episode and the "Yorm cut" jokes, then the hosts debate whether it was Criterion. They check in on the Josh Brolin episode, discussing Fartface, Fall Foliage, the Palin rap, Adele's debut, and the Emmys and WGA awards, before queuing up Jon Hamm's episode as the main topic. The Jon Hamm discussion dissects his Trick or Treat sketch with Jeff Montgomery, followed by Seth's Corner on the Obama "Safe and Musical" cold open and the origin of John Ham. The A-Holes Mad Men crossover with Elisabeth Moss and John Slattery and the James Mason Vincent Price special follow. The episode closes with talk of Hamm as a top host in a five-in-a-row run of hosts and a sign-off.
Heard here, not in the AlmaNick yet
- buttery rust “the toasted oranges the buttery rusts the buttery rusts buttery rust and again god it's just dying”
- Jostian flares “jostian flares are when he wears bellbottoms”
- Andy's handsome “oh it's your mnemonic device andy's handsome lower left andy's handsome akiva's smart seth is a coastal elite”
Shorts discussed: Ross Trent, Fartface, Fall Foliage, Mark Wahlberg talks to animals, Sarah Palin Rap (Weekend Update), Trick or Treat (Jon Hamm), Jon Hamm's John Ham, A-Holes (Mad Men crossover), Obama Address: Safe and Musical (cold open)
Guests: Jorma Taccone (Co-host of the podcast; appears throughout, including in…), Akiva Schaffer (Co-host joining late in the opening; Keev)
← Ep. 50 Ras Trent · Ep. 52 Everyone's a Critic →
Pop-ups (32 · 3 fan picks from YouTube comments)
-
Fans point here
0:422 YouTube comments timestamp this moment, 5 likes.
Pay never. It's the Lonely Island and Seth Meyers Podcast. Yeah! I think Keev's about to join us, and so let's get out the business that Keev doesn't want to talk about.
-
The 2,500th spelling bee
1:07The hosts discuss the first 'S' appearing in the spelling bee, which coincided with its 2,500th edition. The NYT Spelling Bee is a recurring part of the crew's word-game culture.
It was the 2,500th spelling bee.
-
The Yorm cut demand
1:39Listeners kept asking to 'release the Yorm cut' after Jorma's partially recorded Ross Trent episode. Seth jokes that the audio would not be enjoyable.
people yelling, release the Yorm cut.
-
Ross Trent might be Criterion
8:41The hosts debate whether the Ross Trent episode qualifies for the Criterion ranking, citing its specificity and the fact that Rihanna enjoyed the sketch.
do you guys think that this is a criterion collection episode
-
Fans point here
19:304 YouTube comments timestamp this moment, 25 likes.
So, you know, look, Fartface and Fall are two of the most memorable sketches that did not play at all, right? Yeah. Yeah, I mean, Fartface, did Fartface play badly? Because I will say playing it for my 10-year-old son…
— Seth -
Fartface died at dress rehearsal
19:59Fartface reportedly bombed at dress rehearsal yet made it to air. Josh Brolin then told the writers to 'shut these fuckers up' before the broadcast.
Fartface died so much that it died at dress and somehow made it to air.
-
Brolin's crowd-hyping line
20:48Right before the Fartface sketch aired, Josh Brolin reportedly said 'let's shut these fuckers up,' a line the hosts treat as a legendary pep talk.
Brolin said to Forte and Hayter right before they did the sketch at air, let's shut these fuckers up.
-
Fall Foliage's second-half slot
23:59Fall Foliage is another office sketch placed in the second half of the show, which the hosts argue worked against it.
now it's just a different part of an office.
-
Noah Baumbach's guest-writer week
26:25Akiva recalls Noah Baumbach came in as a guest writer and director that week and filmed a short called New York Underground. Past guest directors included Andy Warhol and PTA.
this was the week that Noah Baumbach came by just to do one of those guest director, guest writer weeks.
-
Gun holstered origin
27:04The phrase 'gun holstered' is Akiva's opposite of 'shots fired,' used after something peaceful and uncontroversial. Here it marks his praise of Baumbach and PTA.
Yeah. Shots fired.
-
The Mad Men costume week
27:26Jon Hamm arrives and the cast dresses as Mad Men characters, a costume week the hosts say was never repeated. Andy admits he dressed badly, having not yet watched the show.
We all know him as Don Draper. Everybody dresses up as a madman character.
-
Andy's bad Mad Men costume
27:39Andy recounts dressing as a Mad Men character without having watched the show, wearing a baggy button-up and polka dot tie.
I hadn't seen Mad Men yet and did a bad job of dressing up as Mad Men.
-
Trick or Treat credited to Simon and Mulaney writers
28:30The hosts note the Golden Era writing talent behind this episode, including Simon and Mulaney credited on the Jon Hamm monologue. Seth frames the episode as a peak of the era.
Simon and Mulaney wrote the ham monologue. And then, trick or treat, Jeff Montgomery, the first appearance of Jeff Montgomery.
-
Jeff Montgomery: a pedophile sketch that threads the needle
30:05Trick or Treat is described as a sketch about a registered sex offender knocking on doors, which the hosts argue succeeds where similar premises fail. The Jost, Forte and Solomon writing team is credited.
It's a pedophile sketch, but this one absolutely threads that needle.
-
Jeff Montgomery's 'bitch bitch' opener
31:34The sketch opens with an immediately absurd exchange about Kit Kat bars and toffee, setting an insane tone from the first line.
Hey, don't call me a bitch. You're the bitch bitch. What? Right off the bat. Immediately insane.
-
Deadpan 'I'm a sex offender' Halloween costume
32:44Forte's character reveals his Halloween costume is being a registered sex offender, the sketch's central comedic conceit delivered deadpan.
Deadpan Will, I'm a sex offender.
-
Late line added between dress and air
33:56Seth reads the script notes showing a line was added between dress rehearsal and air, which turned out to improve the sketch without breaking anything.
This is a rare case of they just added this line that gets a big laugh between dress and air. So nothing was broken.
-
Fans point here
40:083 YouTube comments timestamp this moment, 24 likes.
Hey, could you pop me over to Seth's Corner real quick? Seth's Corner, you're all invited. Seth's Corner, it's happening right now. Take it away, Seth. I read a couple of things.
— Seth -
Obama 'Safe and Musical' cold open rehearsal
41:43Seth recalls rehearsing the Obama cold open with Fred Armisen as Obama and Maya Rudolph as Michelle, with Andy as Rahm Emanuel and Akiva as Nancy Pelosi. The sketch was shot the night Amy Poehler had her baby.
One detail here is not in the transcript.
And it was that night Amy had her baby, because this was late Friday.
-
Cold open makeup and quick changes after update
43:20Jorma asks whether big cold opens with heavy makeup make the rest of the show exciting. The cast explains that quick changes are usually scheduled after Weekend Update so departments have time to prepare.
it's often after update because the departments have a lot of time to get ready.
-
John Ham born at Latanzi
43:44Seth describes the moment he came up with the Jon Hamm's Jon Hamm idea: leaving the bathroom at Latanzi, a restaurant where SNL hosts dine, and telling Andy the pitch.
I remember the exact moment I came up with Jon Hamm's Jon Hamm.
-
Latanzi: the secret host dinner spot
44:20Latanzi is the restaurant where Lorne takes the hosts every Tuesday night. Akiva notes it was low-key and secret when the writers worked there, before paparazzi showed up.
It was a cool restaurant because nobody knew about it.
-
Andy's first Latanzi dinner the night he was hired
44:33Andy recalls that his first visit to Latanzi was the night he found out he was hired, and that is where he met Conan O'Brien.
the first time I went was the night I found out I got hired.
-
Jon Hamm's Jon Hamm: the ham you can eat in the bathroom
45:05The sketch's premise was originally pitched by Seth in the bathroom at Latanzi: a product, a ham you can eat in the bathroom. Andy told him to write it up.
Jon Hamm's Jon Hamm, the ham you can eat in the bathroom.
-
Andy confesses he hadn't seen Mad Men yet
45:40Andy admits he had not watched Mad Men when the sketch aired, later calling it one of the best shows ever made after watching it during COVID.
everyone loves Mad Men except me because I hadn't seen it.
-
Ham product tagline and johnhamsjohnham.com
46:00Seth recalls the sketch's fake product tagline and website, johnhamsjohnham.com, a deliberately dumb writing choice he had nearly forgotten.
if it feels like a slice of ham, don't wipe your ass with it.
-
A-Holes: Mad Men crossover with Elisabeth Moss and John Slattery
47:17A-Holes was a period-piece crossover with Mad Men. Elisabeth Moss and John Slattery play themselves, with Moss stepping in when Amy Poehler was out after having a baby.
And both Elizabeth Moss and John Slattery play themselves.
-
West Wing and Peggy as Bartlett's daughter
48:07Andy notes that after watching West Wing, Peggy's role was revealed as Bartlett's daughter, a connection he watched in reverse order during COVID.
So I was like, whoa, Peggy is Bartlett's daughter? That was it.
-
John Slattery Venetian blinds bit cut
48:28A joke to add John Slattery as Venetian blinds for a toilet was tried and cut, because nobody calls Venetian blinds slatteries. Slattery himself knew it was getting cut.
That didn't work because nobody calls Venetian blind slatteries.
-
Vincent Price Halloween special and James Mason rewrite
48:55Hamm was originally set to play JFK at dress rehearsal, then Lorne asked him to switch to a James Mason role between dress and air, requiring a rewrite and a live first-time impression.
Lorne asked him to play James Mason, and we had to rewrite it for James Mason.
-
Hamm's first live James Mason impression
49:04Akiva recalls the cast being impressed that Hamm did a James Mason impression live for the first time, seen as a step beyond a dream host and a sign he would be asked back.
his first time doing it, doing it live on air.
-
Jorma's arm reminder: 'Andy's handsome'
50:09Jorma explains he wrote names on his arm so he could tell the hosts apart on Zoom, and Andy's entry reads 'Andy's handsome,' which the hosts riff on.
I read it on my arm, guys, so I could tell you guys apart.
-
Rasta Man digital short title confusion
51:18Akiva points out that the rundown labeled the Ras Trent sketch as Rasta Man, a title the hosts say they would never use, so the mislabeling seems to be a game of telephone.
Ross Trent was called digital short colon Rasta Man. We would never say Rasta Man.
-
Jorma's 'wear a fucking suit' bit
52:55Seth recalls scolding himself for wearing jeans on the bottom during an update and notes his talk show now has no suit at all, a callback to his earlier style.
ugh, wear a fucking suit. You piece of shit.
-
Five-in-a-row host streak
54:28Seth notes that Hathaway, Brolin, Hamm, Affleck and Rudd hosted consecutively, with Rudd on his fifth time, a strong run for host quality.
find me five better SNL hosts in a row. Ever.
People and sketches mentioned (30)
Seth Meyers Josh Brolin Amy Poehler Noah Baumbach PTA Mark Wahlberg Lorne Michaels Rihanna Marlon James Jeff Montgomery Lorne Lauren Conan O'Brien Amy Poehler Kristen Bobby Jason Fred Maya Mark Wahlberg
Mad Men costume week Fartface Fall Foliage Weekend Update Sarah Palin rap Mad Men West Wing Two Guys sketch / Just Two Guys Noonie sketch Ras Trent (Digital Short) Sushi Glory Hall
Source: whisperx-v2+speakers transcript, read by anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 on 2026-10-21; audio timestamps mapped to the YouTube cut by word alignment. Timestamps shown are YouTube time. Report a bad pop-up.